Member-only story

The Curious Case of Disney's Fake Jeremy Fisher: A Journey into Hidden Film Histories

Jorge Amado

·17.4k Followers· Follow

Published in The Disney Fake Jeremy Fisher

4 min read

646 View Claps

65 Respond

Save

Listen

In the vast and enchanting realm of Disney animation, one would expect to find only official, meticulously crafted productions. However, amidst the beloved classics, lies a curious tale of a non-Disney creation that masqueraded as a genuine Disney masterpiece. This enigmatic piece of lost media has captivated film historians and animation enthusiasts for decades, raising questions about the boundaries of authenticity and the enduring allure of cinematic illusions.

The Origins of Jeremy Fisher

The original Jeremy Fisher was a beloved children's book character created by British author and illustrator Beatrix Potter in 1906. The tales of this anthropomorphic frog's fishing adventures captured the hearts of young readers worldwide.

The Disney Fake Book

by Jeremy Fisher

4.3 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	92276 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	288 pages

In 1936, a mysterious animated short film emerged, claiming to be a Disney production based on Potter's character. This unauthorized film, aptly titled "Jeremy Fisher," showcased a crudely drawn frog protagonist embarking on a series of misadventures. However, upon closer examination, it became evident that this film bore no resemblance to Disney's signature animation style.

The Search for the True Creator

As the "Jeremy Fisher" short gained notoriety, animation historians embarked on a quest to uncover its true origins. Various theories emerged, attributing the film to obscure animators or even a hoax perpetrated by Potter herself.

The breakthrough came in 1989 when animator John Canemaker discovered a series of telltale clues. The film's crude animation, peculiar sound effects, and unusual character movements pointed to a particular animator named Richard Cate.

Richard Cate and His Lost Film

Richard Cate was a talented animator who worked for various animation studios in the 1930s and 1940s. However, Cate's name had faded into obscurity until the discovery of his connection to the "Jeremy Fisher" short.

It is believed that Cate created the film as a personal project, possibly as a demo reel to showcase his skills. In a twist of fate, the film somehow fell into the hands of an unscrupulous distributor who passed it off as a genuine Disney production.

The Disney Deception

How did Cate's film deceive even the most seasoned animation experts? The answer lies in the film's clever marketing and distribution tactics. The distributor utilized promotional materials that falsely claimed the film's affiliation with Disney, misleading audiences into believing it was an official production.

Furthermore, the film's release coincided with a period when Disney was experiencing a surge in popularity. Audiences were eager to consume anything bearing the Disney name, creating a perfect opportunity for the "Jeremy Fisher" hoax to flourish.

The Legacy of the Fake Jeremy Fisher

Despite its unauthorized origins, the "Jeremy Fisher" short has become an iconic piece of lost media. Its enigmatic history and unique animation style have intrigued generations of film enthusiasts.

The film serves as a reminder that even in the realm of entertainment, truth and fiction can intertwine in unexpected ways. It celebrates the ingenuity and determination of a talented animator who, despite not having the official Disney stamp of approval, created a work that continues to fascinate and inspire audiences to this day.